We are looking to restock on TONS of Magic: The Gathering cards! Our buylist has been designed to make the process as easy for you as possible; simply head to the Buylist Builder: https://perfectstormmtg.crystalcommerce.com/buylist/multi_search

From there it is easy to enter your cards to sell! You can enter cards one at a time, OR (!!!) you can paste an entire list and it will search the buylist for all the cards at the same time! From there, it’ s a nice, simple cart-based transaction, just like buying cards from us! You’ll go through the cart and submit your order, then we just need you to bring/ship them to us, once we’ve received them and are able to verify the list and condition, we will contact you for payment. Payment options include

  • Check by mail (or in person pickup at our Battle Creek MI location)
  • PayPal
  • Store Credit (this is the fastest and is processed automatically if you’ve selected store credit payment) – and we always do a boost for Store Credit purchases (currently boost is 30%)
  • If the condition of the cards submitted does not match the list, the offer will be adjusted to reflect the actual condition of the card. We grade very strictly, so please be conservative in your grading.
  • Buylist orders not revieved within 2 weeks of submission will be automatically cancelled – so please contact us if you experience delays.